The Culver-Stockton College Athletic Hall of Fame pays tribute to those men and women or teams who have helped bring recognition and honor to Culver-Stockton on the playing fields and courts; and recognizes individuals who have made outstanding contributions to the overall athletic program.

Criteria for membership:

• The Athletic Hall of Fame shall be composed of athletic lettermen, former and/or present coaches, and other individuals who by deeds show themselves to be outstanding benefactors to Culver-Stockton's athletic program.
• In general, athletes must have had their degree conferred at Culver-Stockton College and been away from C-SC for a minimum of 10 years.
• Coaching nominees must have been a coach for at least five years at Culver-Stockton College. Only accomplishments while coaching at Culver-Stockton will be taken into consideration.
• Those persons or teams who are chosen to be inducted into the Culver-Stockton Athletic Hall of Fame shall be judged by the selection committee as having made an outstanding contribution to C-SC Athletics.

Hall of Fame Inductees:

• 1981
  • Charles Larson '41 (Football/Track and Field)
• 1982
  • William A. Herrington (Coach – Football, Men's Basketball, Baseball/Athletic Director)
• 1983
  • Harvey Dickinson '36 (Track and Field)
  • Robert Wilson '47 (Men's Basketball
• 1984
  • Herb Bunker (Coach – Baseball, Football)
  • Gene Tuggle '28 (Football/Men's Basketball/Track and Field)
• 1985
  • Paul Scott (Coach – Football)
  • Gus Williams '68 (Football)
• 1986
  • Art Hendren '41 (Football)
• 1987
  • Kenneth Robb (Coach – Men's Basketball)
  • Dale Love '42 (Men's Basketball)
• 1988
  • Pete Adkins (Meritorious Service)
  • John Ernst (Men's Basketball)
• 1989
  • James A. Wilson (Meritorious Service)
  • Phillip Morris '58 (Football/Men's Basketball/Baseball)
• 1990
  • Quinn Constantz (Meritorious Service)
  • Fred Friese '41 (Men's Basketball/Track and Field)
• 1991
  • Ken Schuler (Meritorious Service)
  • Harold Kottman '41 (Men's Basketball)
• 1992
  • Ted Owen '31 (Meritorious Service)
• 1993
  • Millard Bondurant '72 (Football/Men's Basketball/Baseball)
• 1994
  • Kathy Turpin (Coach – Women's Basketball)
  • Jim Enlow (Meritorious Service)
• 1995
  • Jack Walz '52 (Men's Basketball/Baseball)
• 1996
  • Frank Gutierrez '73 (Men's Basketball)
• 1997
  • Pam Cottrell '86 (Women's Basketball)
• 1998
  • Gene Hall (Coach – Volleyball/Men's Basketball/Athletic Director)
• 1999
  • Becky Winking '88 (Volleyball/Women's Basketball)
• 2000
  • Brad Eaton '89 (Men's Basketball/Men's Golf/Baseball)
  • 1969 Football Team
• 2001
  • Dale Hendren '47 (Football)
  • Elgie Posey '41 (Football)
  • 1983-84 Women's Basketball Team
• 2002
  • Vic Gragg '54 (Men's Basketball)
  • Mike Owen '88 (Men's Basketball)
  • 1977 Men's Golf Team
  • 1992 Volleyball Team
• 2003
  • Larry Moore '58 (Football/Baseball)
  • Carrie Lynn Connell '93 (Women's Basketball)
  • Dr. Tom Wiltshire '63 (Meritorious Service)
  • 1964-65 Men's Basketball Team
• 2004
  • Dave Marr '58 (Men's Basketball)
  • April Stary '94 (Softball)
  • 1994 Softball Team
• 2005
  • Meleia Musgrove '82 (Women's Basketball/Softball)
  • Bill Zelle '82 (Football)
  • Linda Logsdon '95 (Women's Basketball)
  • 1957 Football Team
• 2006
  • Donna Ayers '79 (Women's Basketball/Softball)
  • Jason Kaiser '96 (Football/Baseball)
  • 1958-59 Men's Basketball Team
• 2007
  • Kelly Winters '89 (Women's Basketball/Softball)
  • Matt Hacker '92 (Men's Soccer)
  • Aron Potter '98 (Softball)
• 2008
  • Kevin Wiley '89 (Football)
  • Jana Larkin '91 (Volleyball)
  • Shelia Suddarth '91 (Women's Basketball/Softball)
  • Steve Zimmerman '98 (Baseball)
• 2009
  • 1939 Football Team
  • 1940 Football Team
  • 1998 Baseball Team
  • Jacob Schneider '99 (Men's Soccer)
• 2010
  • Bruce Rowe ' 70 (Football)
  • Bob Vashinko '70 (Football)
  • Kim (Kipling) Bushmeyer '99 (Volleyball)
  • Rod Walton (Meritorious Service)
  • 1991-92 Women's Basketball Team
• 2011
  • Keith Alexander -70 (Football)
  • Dana (Schutte) Reynolds '99 (Volleyball)
  • Stacy (Stephenson) Turner "00 (Softball)
  • 1961 Baseball Team
• 2012
  • Jeff Stollberg '73 (Men's Basketball)
  • Theresa (Totsch) McGaughey '84 (Women's Basketball)
  • Dan Powers ' 00 (Baseball)
  • 1984-85 Men's Basketball Team